This site is not affiliated with athenahealth, Inc. All pricing sourced independently from public sources. Verify current pricing at athenahealth.com.
athenahealth for Small Practices: Is It Worth the Cost?
athenahealth's collections percentage model was designed for practices that can benefit from managed revenue cycle services. For small practices, the calculus is more complex — and in many cases, flat-rate alternatives offer better value.
The Small Practice Cost Reality
A solo provider collecting $40,000/month pays approximately $2,140/month on athenahealth (5% + $140 base). That's $25,680/year — or 5.35% of gross collections. For comparison, DrChrono costs $349/month (~0.87% of the same collections volume). The difference is that athenahealth includes managed billing; DrChrono does not. Whether athenahealth is worth 4.5× the price depends on how much your billing improves.
Cost Comparison: athenahealth vs Flat-Rate Alternatives
athenahealth at 5% rate vs DrChrono and NextGen (EHR only — add billing costs for DrChrono/NextGen).
| Scenario | Monthly Collections | athenahealth (5%) | DrChrono | NextGen |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Very low volume solo | $15,000 | $890 | $349 | $300 |
| Low volume solo | $30,000 | $1,640 | $349 | $300 |
| Average solo | $50,000 | $2,640 | $349 | $300 |
| High volume solo | $80,000 | $4,140 | $349 | $300 |
| 2-provider group | $150,000 | $7,780 | $698 | $600 |
| 3-provider group | $300,000 | $15,560 | $1,047 | $900 |
DrChrono and NextGen costs are subscription only — add billing service costs (typically 3–5% of collections billed separately) for true comparison. athenahealth includes billing. Bold = cheapest subscription-only option.
When athenahealth Makes Sense for Small Practices
athenahealth is right for small practices when...
- You don't have or don't want an in-house billing team
- Your current denial rate is above 12% (athenahealth averages 5–7%)
- You're a new practice without billing infrastructure
- You want a single vendor for EHR + billing + scheduling
- You're willing to trade higher % cost for zero billing management
- athenahealth's RCM improvement will increase your net collections
Consider alternatives when...
- You already collect 95%+ with efficient billing
- Your monthly collections are under $20,000 (percentage model punishes low volume)
- You want the absolute lowest monthly cost
- You're a mental health or therapy practice (SimplePractice is cheaper)
- You have a very simple specialty with few denial issues
- Budget is the primary concern over billing optimisation
Budget EHR Alternatives for Small Practices
Best for: Solo and 2–5 provider practices, iPad/mobile users
Add 3rd-party billing separately
Best for: Primary care practices wanting modular approach
E-prescribing-first — scale up modules as needed
Best for: Very small primary care practices
Limited specialty support
Best for: Mental health, counselling, behavioural health
Not for medical practices
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the minimum cost for athenahealth for a solo practice?
The minimum estimated cost for a solo provider on athenahealth is approximately $1,300–$1,500/month assuming $30,000/month in collections at a 5% rate ($1,500 collections fee + $140 base = $1,640/month). At lower collections volumes, the effective cost percentage rises. There is no published minimum fee, but implementation costs of $1,000–$3,000 apply upfront.
Is athenahealth good for a 2-3 provider practice?
athenahealth can work well for 2–5 provider practices, particularly if the practice has billing inefficiencies that athenahealth's RCM can address. If your current denial rate is above 12%, athenahealth's managed billing may improve net collections enough to offset the percentage fee. For practices with efficient in-house billing, flat-rate alternatives like DrChrono or Veradigm may offer better value at this size.
What are the cheapest EHR options for solo providers?
The cheapest EHR options for solo providers include: Veradigm (starts at $59/month for e-prescribing, full EHR from $99/month), DrChrono ($199–$349/month for solo providers), SimplePractice ($69–$149/month, best for mental health), and Practice Fusion ($149/month). These flat-rate platforms are significantly cheaper than athenahealth's percentage model at low collections volumes.